Thursday, November 19, 2026 · Hidar 10, 2019 E.C.
The Abay Times

Ethiopia and the World

Explainer

What legal protections do Ethiopians facing execution in Saudi Arabia have?

Saudi law provides appeals and mandatory review of death sentences, but rights groups allege serious failures in migrants' trials.

View of Abha, capital of Saudi Arabia's Asir province, with buildings and hills under a cloudy sky

Abha, the capital of Saudi Arabia's Asir province. File photograph, 2013. Photo: Aiman titi / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Ethiopian migrants sentenced to death in Saudi Arabia have rights to consular contact, legal assistance and judicial review. But those protections do not amount to immunity from execution, and rights investigators say some prisoners have been denied the means to use them.

The question has become urgent for families in Ethiopia. Human Rights Watch reported on 28 July that Saudi Arabia had executed at least 17 Ethiopian nationals for drug-related offences during 2026, including five on 27 July, and that at least 79 more faced imminent execution. Those figures describe the organisation's findings at that date, not a verified current count. In November, further reporting described prisoners still awaiting execution, while a Tigray official separately claimed that 520 Ethiopians were on death row. The latter figure has not been independently established as a national total.

What does Saudi law require before an execution?

Saudi Arabia's Law of Criminal Procedure gives defendants the right to seek a lawyer during investigation and trial. It also provides a process to challenge criminal judgments. Under Article 194, a defendant generally has 30 days to request an appeal or review. Crucially, death sentences must be sent to the court of appeal even if the defendant does not file an appeal.

Advertisement

The procedure does not stop there. The law requires capital judgments upheld by the appeal court to be referred to the Supreme Court for review. This means a prisoner who cannot write an appeal in Arabic should not, merely for that reason, lose the mandatory judicial scrutiny of a death sentence.

These safeguards matter particularly in cases involving people who do not understand Arabic. A formal opportunity to appeal is not the same as a meaningful opportunity to challenge evidence if a defendant cannot understand the accusation, the judgment or the documents they are asked to sign.

Human Rights Watch described five Ethiopians executed in July who, according to people familiar with their cases, had no legal representation and attended three hearings lasting between three and 20 minutes. Two hearings took place remotely. The organisation said interpretation was available at only two sessions and the men had been made to sign Arabic documents they did not understand. It also reported that at least one defendant had to ask another prisoner to write an appeal and did not know whether it reached a court.

Saudi authorities have maintained in execution announcements that sentences passed through the required judicial stages. That assertion and the reported experiences of prisoners leave an important distinction: a judgment can be formally reviewed without the accused having had a fair opportunity to defend themselves.

Can Ethiopia demand access to its prisoners?

Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations protects communication between detained foreign nationals and their consular officials. Saudi authorities must inform detainees without delay of their right to have their consulate notified, and must notify it without delay if the detainee requests this. Consular officials may visit nationals in detention, communicate with them and arrange legal representation.

The provision does not require Saudi Arabia to release an Ethiopian prisoner or let Ethiopian diplomats overturn a Saudi judgment. It does give Ethiopia a recognised route to identify detainees, establish contact, assist families and help obtain lawyers and information about proceedings.

Human Rights Watch reported in April that some Ethiopian detainees had received no consular visits or contact. That allegation is significant because an embassy cannot provide effective individual assistance without knowing who is detained, where they are held and what legal stage their cases have reached.

Is execution for a drug offence lawful internationally?

Saudi law allows capital punishment for certain drug-related offences. International human rights standards are considerably narrower. United Nations human rights bodies interpret the restriction of capital punishment to the 'most serious crimes' as excluding non-lethal drug offences. The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention has criticised Saudi executions for such offences.

A legal qualification matters here: Saudi Arabia is not a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, whose Article 6 contains the most-serious-crimes limitation. It is therefore inaccurate to describe every obligation in that treaty as directly binding on Saudi Arabia. The country is, however, party to the Convention against Torture, and allegations of coerced confessions, beatings and grossly unfair proceedings engage separate international legal obligations.

The African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights, in a statement dated 22 July, invoked the right to life and fair-trial guarantees in the African Charter and urged Ethiopia to pursue diplomatic and legal measures. The Charter binds Ethiopia as a party; the Commission's appeal does not itself operate as an order binding a Saudi court.

What can be done after a death sentence?

Lawyers acting for a prisoner can examine whether the judgment went through the mandatory review stages, whether interpretation and legal assistance were adequate, whether evidence was coerced and whether a further legally available application or request for reconsideration is possible. The exact remedy depends on the case file and procedural status; it cannot be assumed that a normal appeal remains open after a sentence becomes final.

Ethiopian diplomats can request consular access, help secure independent lawyers, seek information about the convictions and press for a halt, commutation or clemency through Saudi authorities. Families can supply identities, detention locations and available case records, although diplomatic intervention does not guarantee a reprieve.

On 13 July, Ethiopia's Foreign Ministry said it remained closely engaged with Saudi authorities over nationals facing legal proceedings and judicial measures. On 22 July, the African Commission called on Ethiopia to ensure legal representation, interpretation, family communication and consular protection, and to seek review of convictions and death sentences.

The immediate unanswered issue is case-specific: for each Ethiopian facing execution, was a lawyer available, did the prisoner understand the proceedings, were allegations of coercion investigated, and did the mandatory appeal and Supreme Court reviews take place? Without the judgments and review records, public claims about procedural compliance cannot resolve those questions.

Related Stories

Advertisement